Black background , Rusty , wood , ax

Who murdered Mary Murphy?

This is a sneak peek into Edition 30 of Traces!

Phillip Keith Johnson investigates the mysterious 1879 cold-case murder of young Mary Murphy, whose husband, James Murphy, was the prime suspect.

James Murphy, son of James Murphy (Senior) and Catherine Fitzgerald, was born on 17 February 1832 in Summerhill, County Meath, Ireland. Aged 22, he migrated to Australia with his brother, William, where they joined their parents, who had migrated several years earlier. James’s sister, Bridget, remained in Ireland to marry Francis Burke, and later joined the Murphy family in Monaro, New South Wales.

James and his siblings had survived Ireland’s Great Famine and the depressed economic conditions of their homeland. Upon arriving in Australia, James acquired a small, fertile 40-acre portion of land at Cathcart, New South Wales, on the bank of the Dragon Swamp, which is a series of connected freshwater holes that do not dry up even during severe drought. It was here that his wife was murdered.

James married Mary Cosgrove in 1859 in Cooma, New South Wales. She was the daughter of Charles and Mary Cosgrove from Dublin, Ireland. On the property, they had built a two-roomed hut comprising a kitchen and dining area, plus a bedroom. Supporting the family was a vegetable garden and fruit trees, and, together, James and Mary worked the farm. People in the district also knew that Mary would plough the paddock with oxen when James was away shearing. Mary also had a cow to milk, calves to feed and general farm duties. People described Mary as hardworking and industrious, as well as a kind-hearted and genial soul.

James was a shearer and worked on the surrounding properties at shearing times using hand shears. Mary and James worked and saved hard as Mary desired to visit Ireland, the land of her birth. James and Mary customarily went to bed early and woke up early, and it was rare to see candlelight in their home at night. They had no children, and James was a good and respected worker. The hut where James and Mary lived was close to James’ brother William’s property, where he lived with his wife, also named Mary. There were two other houses about 1.2 kilometres away.

On Sunday 10 December 1879, James mounted his horse and cantered 16 kilometres to Bibbenluke Station to prepare for the shearing that would begin the next day, leaving Mary on her own, as was their custom. That night, an unknown person took Mary’s life.

The next day, people reported that someone appeared to have dragged Mary Murphy out of her bed and bludgeoned her with an axe. It was also supposed that the murderer had violated Mary. The Empire newspaper reported on 17 December 1871 that Mary Murphy was found in her nightdress about 30 yards (27 metres) from the house, covered by a blanket. Mary is rumoured to have tried to escape when the murderer was entering the house, but received a blow to the back of her head with an axe.

To read the rest of the story, check out the latest edition of Traces.

Image courtesy of iStock

Subscribe and save!

So many reasons to dig even deeper into fascinating stories from Australia's past:
  • Save up to 30% off the RRP
  • Receive FREE digital access to all online editions!
  • Never miss an issue with home delivery.
Edition 36 out now!

Explore more

Musquito: legendary colonial warrior 

Branded an outlaw and a resistance leader, Musquito has long been one of the most contested figures in Australia’s frontier history. In Edition 36 of Traces, Naomi Parry Duncan explores the events that led to his capture near Parramatta in 1805, and reflects on her own unexpected connection to Musquito’s story.

Read Story

AI as your research companion 

By Maureen Martin Ferris  When used carefully, artificial intelligence can serve as a valuable research companion for the family historian, offering powerful tools to support, assist and streamline your work.  Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming the way we live and work, and genealogical research is no exception. When used well, it can act as a powerful

Read Story